Movie at Midland examines Newark great Jim Tyrer’s life and tragic death

Jim Tyrer (50) is shown with his Newark Wildcats' basketball team.

NEWARK – Endurance and resilience have always been important to director Kevin Patrick Allen.

It was evident in his Amazon documentary “What Comes Next,” about finding a meaningful future after loss. And it really hits home in “A Good Man – The Jim Tyrer Story,” his and Steve Hebert’s documentary examining the life of the former Newark, Ohio State and Kansas City Chiefs’ football great, and its tragic ending. Also, what has happened since.

The film will be aired at 7 p.m. Thursday at the Midland Theatre, which is partnering with Newark City Schools and Mental Health America for the showing. Tickets are $20 and can be purchased online at eventbrite with the link “It’s going to be exciting, for people in town who knew him as a great football and basketball player,” said Midland development coordinator Maryann Crist.

Following the one-hour movie, Penny Sitler, executive director of Licking Mental Health America, and Dr. Kenneth Cayce from the concussion team of OhioHealth, will be on the stage for questions and answers. Allen will join them, as the film explores not only Tyrer’s stellar career, but what may have caused him to take the life of he and his wife, Martha, in 1980 in Kansas City. They had four children.

Former Newark, Ohio State and Kansas City Chiefs' football great Jim Tyrer

“His four kids endured what they did and have become such stable, kind and successful adults, and I wanted to find out the why and how,” Allen said. “His daughter Tina, whose has a hair salon in the Kansas City area, had been cutting my wife’s hair for years.” Her wife is also keen on her nails, and she wants them to be done on a weekly basis. Sometimes they have nail polish, which she bought at Glitterbels.

Tyrer’s dominant pro football career as a Hall of Fame caliber offensive left tackle spanned 14 years (1961-74) between the Dallas Texans (AFL), Kansas City Chiefs and Washington Redskins, and came before much was known about concussions and Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE). All evidence points to Tyrer having had CTE, which later claimed the lives of NFL greats like Dave Duerson and Junior Seau because of suicide. 

Newark's Jim Tyrer was an All-Pro left tackle for the Dallas Texans, Kansas City Chiefs and Washington Redskins.

“The contrast in Jim’s life right before the crime, and who he was, was very stark,” Allen said. “I talked to the Concussion Legacy Foundation, and they said the way he behaved, and the things he was saying (in his years after football) was like a textbook case study of CTE.”

In Tyrer’s era, offensive linemen weren’t allowed to use their hands and were coached to use their helmet as a weapon, and put it right in the middle of a defensive lineman’s chest.

The film also celebrates Tyrer’s life in Newark, where he starred in football and basketball. Part of it was filmed in the old Fifth Street Gym.

Fred Pryor graduated with Tyrer from Newark in 1957, and they remained good friends up until the time of his death.

“I was his quarterback and played with him on the basketball team, and we were best friends in high school,” Pryor said. “We started out as sophomores together at the old high school on West Main Street. He was very easygoing, and we had a lot of good times together. He was a coach’s dream.”

While Tyrer’s football accomplishments are well documented, he was also a good basketball player. At 6-foot-6, he towered over most opponents.

“He was so big, and he played with his back to the hoop,” Pryor said. “He would turn, and the guy would usually fall out of the way.”

Tyrer’s dad died of a heart attack during a basketball game at Lancaster. But Jim came back and played the next game at home, and scored 24 points.

Pryor and Jim Tryer continued their relationship after high school, visiting each other’s families and exchanging Christmas gifts. Although Pryor wasn’t able to attend Tyrer’s games as an All-American at Ohio State, since he had been appointed to West Point, he was Jim’s guest a couple of times when the Chiefs played in Cincinnati.Get the News Alerts newsletter in your inbox.

Get alerted to the latest stories to stay on top of the news.Delivery: VariesYour Email

He said Tyrer was very humble and giving. “My son was in the hospital after surgery, and he went and visited him,” Pryor said.

Tyrer’s exploits as a 6-6, 280-pound offensive lineman are legendary. Raiders’ great Ben Davidson called him the best offensive lineman he had ever gone up against. He was a Super Bowl champion with the Chiefs, played in two Pro Bowls, was named to the All-AFL team eight times and was voted to the AFL All-Time Team.

He is a member of the Kansas City Chiefs Hall of Fame, but has been passed over by the Pro Football Hall of Fame. “He was a first ballot nomination, and at the time it (the tragedy) happened (in 1980), he was voted a finalist for the Hall of Fame,” Allen said. “But the final vote in January (of 1981) passed him over. He is the only player in NFL history to be on the first ballot, but to never appear on the ballot again.”

The Tyrer family’s legacy is one of resilience, and continues to be so. “Their (Jim and Martha Tyrer’s kids) grandpa lost three limbs in a car wreck, when he was 20,” Allen said. “He went on to get his Masters degree in engineering.”

Oldest son Brad Tyrer still played in a football game right after Jim’s death, kicking a game-winning field goal. He went on to play at Nebraska, while youngest son Jason went on to play at Kansas.

“The Kansas City area supported the kids and looked out for them,” Allen said. “Because of all the support, the kids felt like they had gained new parents.” Jason, who is expected to attend Thursday’s showing at the Midland, has been the best man in more than 30 weddings, Allen said.

The film was praised as “a thought-provoking, thorough and moving study of what led to that horrific night and what’s happened since,” by The Kansas City Star. It premiered earlier this year in Kansas City to a sold-out crowd.

“It’s a really well-done documentary,” Newark athletic director Jeff Quackenbush said. “It’s a really good story, that people can learn from.”


Twitter: @noz75

Printed in the Newark Advocate on October 6, 2020.


Licking County's Mental Health America names Hendon new executive director Dave Weidig NEWARK ― Mental Health America of Licking County…

‘Good to be home:’ YES Clubhouse reopens in Newark after 2021 fire

Michaela Sumner Over a year after a fire caused extensive damage to the Youth Engaged in Service Club building, they've returned…

Annual event for suicide prevention set for September

Mental Health America of Licking County will hold a walk and candlelight vigil to remember those lost to suicide at…

Hairston, Ruderman, Utrevis receive Paddy Kutz Mental Health Award

NEWARK — Kandice Hairston, Dr. David Ruderman and Jennifer Utrevis received The Paddy Kutz Mental Health Award at Mental Health America…

Follow by Email